摘 要
人民法院司法体制改革正如火如荼地进行。司法责任制被誉为当代中国司法改革的“牛鼻子”。实行法官办案质量责任终身制是“让审理者裁判,由裁判者负责”的内在要求,是我国司法正义实现的途经之一。当前社会下,我国法官办案质量责任终身制在推动法治进程方面取得了一定成效,然而其缺陷也逐渐显露,倘若放任不管,审判权的行使必然会受到权责分离的阻碍,制约司法公正性与权威性的有效实现。因此,应当紧紧把握司法改革的主脉,以司法公正、高效、透明为追求,对法官办案质量责任终身制度予以反思、剖析。
关键词:法官 办案质量责任终身制 司法改革 冤假错案
The case handling quality lifelong responsibility system
Abstract
Current society, the case handling quality lifelong responsibility system in the process of promoting the rule of law in China has achieved some success, but the profound connotation and relevant system defects are gradually revealed, if left it unchecked, exercise of jurisdiction will be the seperation of obstacles restricting the effective realization of judicial impartiality and authority. Court of justice system is in full swing. Judicial accountability of judicial reform in contemporary China is known as the “key”. Implementation of the quality responsibility of judges life tenure is “let the trial judge, the judge is responsible for” the inherent requirements, is one of China’s judicial justice through.Therefore, grasp the major directions of judicial reform to realize judicial justice and efficiency, it is necessary to judge he case handling quality lifelong responsibility system for the quality of life. Implementation of the case handling quality lifelong responsibility system is “let the trial judge, the judge is responsible for” the inherent requirements, is one of China’s judicial justice through.
Key Words: Judge The case handing quality lifelong responsibility system Judicial reform Miscarriages of justice
一、引言
二、法官办案质量责任终身制的内涵
三、我国法官办案质量责任终身制的形成路径
四、我国法官办案质量责任终身制存在问题
(一)“错案”标准不明确
(二)“终身制”易被误读
(三)责任主体模糊
(四)“责任豁免”雾里看花
(五)法官保障机制未跟进
五、完善法官办案质量责任终身制的建议
(一)健全法官依法独立办案机制
(二)完善法官办案质量责任终身制的制度内容
(三)强化法官任职保障机制
结语